Liberals deny Remembrance Day ‘prayer ban,’ despite Conservative claim

Article content

Conservatives are blaming the Liberal government for a directive that will once again require military chaplains to tone down religious language when speaking at Remembrance Day ceremonies and other public events.

Conservative MP Chris Warkentin said in question period Friday that the so-called “prayer ban” undercuts the spiritual significance of Remembrance Day for both chaplains and many in the broader military community.

Article content

“Remembrance Day is a time for reflection and healing and hope, and for many veterans praying is part of that journey,” said Warkentin.

He called the directive “draconian.”

Parliamentary secretary for defence, Marie-France Lalonde, was quick to dismiss this accusation, saying Warkentin was both misrepresenting the directive and playing partisan games over a matter that was out of the government’s hands.

“Let’s be absolutely clear,” said Lalonde. “The Chaplain General issued the directive independently, and it does not ban prayer.”

“Actually, the directive simply seeks to help our chaplains make their public addresses more inclusive to reflect the spiritual diversity of Canadians and (Armed Forces) members,” she continued.

The new directive was issued to military chaplains last October in response to a major Supreme Court of Canada decision on religious neutrality, swapping out the term “public prayer” with “public reflection.”

The directive requires chaplains to “carefully choose words that are inclusive” when leading public reflections; further instructing them to “employ a language mindful of the Gender Based Analysis (GBA+) principles, incorporate elements in both official languages, and include the use of local languages when appropriate.”

Article content

Article content

Chaplains who don’t comply could face “remedial” disciplinary and administrative actions, per the directive’s enforcement provisions.

Chaplain General J.L.G. Bélisle indicated in the directive that the Supreme Court has “strict standard for religious neutrality by the state, which the (military) has a legal obligation to abide by.”

Bélisle nevertheless agreed last November to put a temporary pause on the directive after receiving multiple complaints, meaning that Remembrance Day ceremonies went forward under the old rules.

A committee was subsequently set up to further review the new policy but it has yet to issue any recommendations.

Defence Minister Bill Blair accused the Conservatives of unfairly attacking Bélisle’s reputation.

“Any suggestion that our Chaplain General banned prayer is disrespectful to the excellent work that our chaplains do in tending to the spiritual well-being of all members of the Canadian Armed Forces,” Blair told National Post.

Article content

Royal Canadian Legion spokesperson Nujma Bond also rejected the Conservatives’ characterization of the new policy as a prayer ban.

“While military chaplains are required to modify their language, that decision does not eliminate the inclusion of prayer to God or a higher power by other spiritual representatives at Legion ceremonies,” said Bond in an email.

“Prayer will remain an important part of Remembrance Day ceremonies organized by the Legion, including the one at the National War Memorial.”

National Post
rmohamed@postmedia.com

Get more deep-dive National Post political coverage and analysis in your inbox with the Political Hack newsletter, where Ottawa bureau chief Stuart Thomson and political analyst Tasha Kheiriddin get at what’s really going on behind the scenes on Parliament Hill every Wednesday and Friday, exclusively for subscribers. Sign up here.

Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted, here.

Article content