Politics

Senate Confirms Two Circuit Judges on Nov. 16 and 17, Votes 51-46 and 52-46

The Senate confirmed Daniel Domenico for the Tenth Circuit on Nov. 16 and Anna St. John for the Fifth Circuit on Nov. 17, by 51-46 and 52-46 votes.

By Victor HaleNovember 18, 20263 min read
Senate Confirms Two Circuit Judges on Nov. 16 and 17, Votes 51-46 and 52-46

The U.S. Senate confirmed Daniel Desmond Domenico, of Colorado, as a United States circuit judge for the Tenth Circuit on Monday, Nov. 16, 2026, by a vote of 51-46. On Tuesday, Nov. 17, it confirmed Anna St. John, of Louisiana, as a circuit judge for the Fifth Circuit, 52-46.

The two confirmations came about 21 hours apart. Both appear in the Senate’s official roll call record for the 119th Congress, second session, which lists each vote’s date, time, question and tally.

Domenico Confirmed 51-46 on Nov. 16

Roll Call Vote No. 263 was taken at 5:27 p.m. on Monday, Nov. 16. The question was “On the Nomination,” for Daniel Desmond Domenico, of Colorado, to be a United States circuit judge for the Tenth Circuit. A majority of those voting was required.

The Senate recorded 51 yeas and 46 nays. Three senators did not vote: Moody (R-FL), Murphy (D-CT) and Risch (R-ID). The Judiciary Committee’s list of confirmed nominees shows the same 51-46 result under Record Vote No. 263.

Senators also held a cloture vote on his nomination on Nov. 12. Vote No. 261 was agreed to 51-27.

Circuit courts are the U.S. courts of appeals, which sit below the Supreme Court. The U.S. Courts website says there are 13 such appellate courts, and that they review whether a trial court or a federal administrative agency applied the law correctly.

Vote Record
Senate Roll Call Vote No. 265 on Nov. 17, 2026 recorded the confirmation of Anna St. John to the Fifth Circuit, 52 yeas and 46 nays, with two senators not voting.

Votes on H.R. 2347 Came in the Same Week

Three votes in the Senate record for the week concern H.R. 2347. On Nov. 9, Vote No. 257 agreed to cloture on the motion to proceed to the bill, 73-25. On Nov. 10, Vote No. 258 agreed to the motion to proceed, 62-21.

Also on Nov. 16, Roll Call Vote No. 264 agreed to cloture by 70-27 on an amendment in the nature of a substitute, No. 6883, the Capito amendment to H.R. 2347.

The vote is dated Nov. 16, the same day as the Domenico confirmation.

St. John Confirmed 52-46 on Nov. 17

Roll Call Vote No. 265 was taken at 2:15 p.m. on Tuesday, Nov. 17, on the nomination of Anna St. John, of Louisiana, to be a United States circuit judge for the Fifth Circuit (PN1181-7). The question required a simple majority. The Senate recorded 52 yeas and 46 nays. Two senators did not vote: Murphy (D-CT) and Risch (R-ID).

Her nomination had reached the floor earlier. Vote No. 262, on Nov. 12, was a cloture vote on the nomination and was recorded at 49-26.

The committee’s judicial nominations page shows her nomination with a unanimous consent agreement for a vote on 11/17/2026 and does not list her as confirmed. The Senate’s roll call record shows the confirmation on Nov. 17. The two sources conflict on her status.

The two confirmations came about 21 hours apart.

Other Judicial Nominees and Pending Cloture Motions

Gregory Carl Cook, nominated for the Northern District of Alabama, was agreed to for cloture 50-27 on Nov. 12 under Vote No. 259. He was confirmed 49-27 under Vote No. 260 the same day.

The committee’s judicial nominations page lists cloture motions presented in the Senate, dated 11/11/2026, for Kyle Reardon (D. Alaska), Daniel Ballou (E.D. Ky.), Richard Bennett (S.D. Tex.) and Courtney Coker (N.D. Tex.). It lists the nomination of Lee Rudofsky (8th Cir.) as withdrawn, under a message dated 11/10/2026.

Some other nominees were received and referred to the Judiciary Committee on dates from Nov. 9 to Nov. 16, 2026. Gregory Todd Butler (5th Cir.), Philip Axt (D.N.D.), Bradford J. Kelley (E.D. La.) and Samuel D. Adkisson (E.D. Tenn.) had hearings held on 11/10/2026.

Senate votes 259 through 262 were taken on Nov. 12, and votes 263 through 265 on Nov. 16 and 17.